Prop 137 Myth-Busters: Commercial Logging

Forest Thinning for Wildfire Risk Reduction is NOT Commercial Logging or Clear-Cutting

Opponents of Prop 137 falsely claim the measure is a green light for commercial logging and clear-cutting. Here is the truth: Prop 137 will help reduce the threat of wildfire statewide through science-backed, forest maintenance best practices to protect our communities and water. Forest thinning for wildfire risk reduction is NOT commercial logging or clear-cutting.

That’s why a broad coalition of community leaders and conservation organizations supports Prop 137, including Conservation Colorado, The Nature Conservancy, Trust for Public Land, the National Wildlife Federation, Western Resource Advocates, Environmental Defense Fund, The Wilderness Society, NRDC Action Fund, Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership, Backcountry Hunters and Anglers, and more.

And while opponents say, “you cut trees, it’s logging,” forest scientists, land managers, wildfire experts, and the broader environmental community reject that claim. Colorado has not had a viable logging industry for decades, and Prop 137 will not create one.

Myth vs. Fact

MYTH: Prop 137 is just a cover for commercial logging and clear-cutting.

FACT: Forest thinning is an essential wildfire risk reduction tool, not commercial logging.

Commercial logging is driven by the timber industry and can involve the clear-cutting of large stands of mature trees. Prop 137, by contrast, funds targeted forest thinning. It’s critical work that costs money rather than making any. This precise, scientifically managed process includes removing small, overgrown brush and dangerously dense trees — called “ladder fuels” — that allow fires to climb into the forest canopy, where flames move faster and are harder to fight. Thinning restores forests to their natural, resilient state; it does not clear-cut them.

Source: From Overgrowth to Renewal 

QUOTABLE: “We are not talking about backcountry logging. This is community-based, smaller-scale funding for work on one to 300 acres adjacent to where people live. We have got to do something now. We have to do the right thing to protect these watersheds or we are going to lose them.”

— Scott Fitzwilliams, the former head of the White River National Forest, the busiest forest in the nation.

MYTH: Cutting trees doesn't actually stop or slow down wildfires

FACT: The data proves forest thinning significantly reduces fire severity.

Overgrown forests and hazardous fuel loads present serious risks for many Colorado communities. A recent, comprehensive analysis of peer-reviewed scientific research found that forest thinning, especially when paired with prescribed fire, reduces wildfire severity by up to 72%. By reducing the density of the forest, land managers can restore natural forest conditions to help fires stay closer to the ground, where they are less destructive and easier for firefighters to control.

Source: ScienceDirect Meta-Analysis on Wildfire Severity

QUOTABLE: “We found overwhelming evidence that mechanical thinning with prescribed burning, mechanical thinning with pile burning, and prescribed burning only are effective at reducing subsequent wildfire severity, resulting in reductions in severity between 62% and 72% relative to untreated areas.”

— Authors of the 2024 Meta-Analysis

MYTH: Leaving the forest completely alone is the best way to protect nature

FACT: Inaction leads to catastrophic, unnatural mega-fires

A century of fire suppression has left our forests unnaturally dense and less able to recover after wildfire. Without restoring natural forest conditions, forests become dense, overgrown landscapes with massive fuel loads. Thinning not only helps prevent these disastrous mega-fires that put our communities at risk, but recent studies also show it improves ecosystem health by increasing drought resilience and helping preserve crucial winter snowpack.
Sources: UW News – Forest thinning and snowpack resilience and Fast-moving wildfires leave forests less able to recover, study finds

MYTH: There are no guidelines or guardrails on the wildfire mitigation

FACT: Prop 137 includes detailed criteria for project funding

Prop 137 includes specific language directing funding to projects that mitigate wildfire risk in Coloradans’ backyards, mostly within 1-2 miles of the built environment. By law, these programs prioritize the protection of people, property, and water in high wildfire risk areas, and the guidelines direct investment in:

  • Proactive work to help prevent severe wildfires.
  • Restoration of areas susceptible to flood and erosion after a wildfire.
  • Defensible space projects.
  • Community planning for wildfire protection.
  • Workforce development.

Prop 137 will not fund large-scale forest management projects in roadless or backcountry areas. No permanent infrastructure or roads can be funded by Prop 137.

QUOTABLE: “Prop 137 supports local, regional, and state-level change that prepares our communities for wildfires and keeps our homes, lands, and waters protected. Wildfire preparedness is generational; community-based solutions and state-led funding are key. If you want to ensure that our kids and future generations can also enjoy the places we love as Coloradans today, then a ‘yes’ on Prop 137 is a priority.”

— Jennifer Mueller, CEO of The Ember Alliance